Butterfly species considered more beautiful by humans are more likely to attract scientific attention and receive legal protection under European conservation rules, according to an international study involving researchers from the University of Białystok.
The findings point to a “beauty bias” in nature conservation, with colourful butterflies and those bearing distinctive wing patterns receiving more attention than less conspicuous species, potentially leaving some overlooked when protection priorities are set.
“We noticed that high levels of interest in specific species do not always reflect their actual status in the wild. Some butterflies that are less conspicuous and receive less attention may also require protection; for instance, because they are rare or inhabit disappearing habitats. We wanted to determine whether such bias truly exists or if it was merely our impression,” says study co-author Marta Skowron Volponi, PhD, from the University of Białystok's Faculty of Biology.
Skowron Volponi and fellow Polish researcher Marcin Wiórek, PhD, from the Institute of Systematics and Evolution of Animals of the Polish Academy of Sciences, took part in the project coordinated by the University of Florence. The researchers investigated whether perceived beauty was linked to scientific interest, public attention and the inclusion of butterfly species in European conservation regulations.
To establish which butterflies people considered beautiful, the team conducted an online survey asking participants to rate photographs of insects. The survey was translated into multiple languages and distributed in more than 100 countries, collecting over 21,000 responses from a broad range of people, not just scientists and nature enthusiasts.
The large number of ratings allowed the researchers to identify common preferences despite individual differences in taste. Butterflies with bright colours and distinctive patterns, including large spots and eyespots on their wings, tended to receive the highest ratings.
“It turns out, however, that this is not entirely the case; there are specific traits these animals have that we perceive as the most attractive,” Skowron Volponi says.
The researchers then compared the beauty ratings with data on scientific research, public interest and the inclusion of species in key European conservation regulations.
They found that both scientists and the wider public tended to focus more on species considered attractive. According to the authors, this can create a self-reinforcing cycle: greater scientific interest generates more knowledge about a species, making it easier to demonstrate why it should be protected.
“The more extensive the body of scientific knowledge about a given butterfly, the easier it is to justify the need for its protection and include it in relevant regulations,” Skowron Volponi says.
One example is the Apollo butterfly, a large white species with distinctive red spots on its wings that scored highly in the beauty survey. It also has a long history of conservation, with some of Europe's earliest calls for special protection concerning the species.
By contrast, less striking butterflies may attract fewer researchers, leaving less information available to assess their populations and conservation needs.
“In contrast, less striking species are less frequently studied and we know less about them, which makes it difficult to assess their status and demonstrate that they require conservation measures. That does not mean, however, that they do not need them,” Skowron Volponi adds.
The team examined whether this beauty bias was reflected in two major European conservation instruments: the Bern Convention and the EU Habitats Directive.
The Bern Convention, adopted in 1979, is an international agreement to protect wild plants, animals and their habitats. The EU Habitats Directive, adopted in 1992, is a cornerstone of the bloc's nature conservation legislation and helps underpin the Natura 2000 network of protected areas.
The researchers found that visually attractive butterfly species were disproportionately represented in both instruments, with the bias particularly pronounced in the Habitats Directive.
“We found a very strong bias in the Habitats Directive. If you look at the butterflies prioritised there, the majority are highly colourful and beautiful,” Skowron Volponi says.
However, the researchers found no comparable overrepresentation of beautiful butterflies in the European Red Lists compiled by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN). This suggests that the scientific assessment of extinction risk itself did not favour species considered more attractive.
That distinction is important because appearing on a Red List does not automatically confer legal protection. Beauty bias may also affect conservation indirectly, however, by influencing which species are studied in the first place and how much is known about them.
“If small, brown butterflies have been studied less frequently over the years, there may simply be a lack of data on their numbers, range, or population trends. In such a situation, it is impossible to accurately assess their level of threat,” Skowron Volponi says.
The authors stress that their findings are not an argument for withdrawing protection from visually striking species. Instead, they say conservation decisions should be based on the needs of each species, regardless of its appearance.
“Each case is different, and every individual species - whether it is beautiful or considered ugly - should be evaluated in the same way,” she says.
The researchers hope their findings will encourage conservation authorities and scientists to recognise how aesthetic preferences can shape decisions about wildlife. Although beauty can help attract public interest and support for protecting nature, they argue, it should not determine which species receive attention and protection.
“This isn't about ignoring nature's beauty. It's about recognising the implicit biases that have shaped European conservation,” say the study's lead authors, Leonardo Dapporto and Mariagrazia Portera.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2026.07.049
Katarzyna Czechowicz (PAP)
kap/ agt/
tr. RL