Human

Polish researcher probes return of deportations to danger zones

Adobe Stock
Adobe Stock

Western governments are resuming deportations to countries once considered too dangerous for forced returns, a University of Warsaw researcher says, as she launches a study into why such deportations are becoming acceptable again.

Agnieszka Radziwinowiczówna, who has received a European Research Council (ERC) Starting Grant to investigate the phenomena, says her REDIRECT project will compare policies in Poland, Germany and the United States, focusing on deportations to Afghanistan, Syria, Ukraine and Venezuela.

Radziwinowiczówna, from the University of Warsaw's Centre of Migration Research, describes the phenomenon as the “re-legitimisation of deportation”. The term refers to a process in which deportations that were previously restricted, contested or considered problematic are once again presented as justified and feasible.

“I am interested not only in why states carry out deportations, but also in how — and under what conditions — deportations become possible and acceptable again,” she told PAP.

She defines deportation broadly as the state-organised removal of a non-citizen from a country's territory. This can include people without valid residence permits as well as those who have completed prison sentences.

The researcher hypothesises that renewed efforts to deport people do not necessarily reflect improvements in safety in the countries to which they are sent. Instead, political and social developments in the countries carrying out the deportations may be more important.

“Deportations are being re-legitimised, even though the situation in the destination countries has not changed radically. I posit that the drivers of this process are primarily socio-political situations in the countries from which people are being deported, rather than in the countries to which they are being sent,” she said.

For this reason, the project will not examine deportation solely from a legal perspective. Radziwinowiczówna will also investigate its social, political and discursive dimensions, looking at when deportation becomes socially acceptable, how it is justified in public debate and what makes it politically possible.

“Is a change in the law sufficient? A new political crisis? War? A shift in how individuals facing deportation are portrayed? Or perhaps a combination of several such factors is required?” she asked.

The researcher said the re-legitimisation of deportation had not previously been established as a distinct subject of research. REDIRECT aims to explain how deportation practices that were once restricted can be reinstated, which institutions and arguments are used to justify them, and why governments and societies come to accept them under certain circumstances.

Comparing Poland, Germany and the United States

The three countries offer different migration systems, historical experiences and approaches to migration control. In recent years, however, all have faced questions about whether people can be returned to countries considered unstable or dangerous, and under what conditions.

The project will examine deportations to Afghanistan, Syria, Ukraine and Venezuela. These cases will allow Radziwinowiczówna to compare different circumstances, from long-running conflicts and instability to full-scale war and political and social crises.

“The goal is not to create a list of the most dangerous destinations for deportation, but rather to understand the mechanism by which deporting someone to a country perceived as dangerous can, over time, come to be presented as feasible, justified, and acceptable,” she said.

One of the central questions is how deportation relates to state sovereignty. Politicians and scholars often regard deportation as an expression of a state's authority to decide who can remain within its territory and to enforce decisions requiring people to leave.

But deportations to dangerous countries can expose the limits of that authority, particularly when carrying them out depends on negotiations with other governments.

Germany's approach to Afghanistan provides one example. Following the withdrawal of US troops and the Taliban's seizure of power, Germany halted deportations to the country. Deportations resumed in 2024 with mediation by Qatar. By 2026, Germany had opted for direct negotiations with the Taliban, despite not officially recognising their government.

“In this sense, deportation — theoretically meant to be an expression of a state’s sovereignty — can, in practice, reveal its dependence on other states,” Radziwinowiczówna said.

The researcher will also compare Polish and German policies towards Ukraine. Following Russia's full-scale invasion in 2022, Poland did not halt deportations to Ukraine, whereas Germany suspended them.

“In my comparative research, I will analyse why, for instance, Germany suspended deportations to Ukraine while Poland did not. This will allow me to see what the degree of state sovereignty depends on, and at what point, rather than being an expression of a state’s independent decision, deportation becomes contingent upon other nations,” she said.

By comparing these cases, Radziwinowiczówna hopes to establish when deportation remains a decision made independently by a state and when it becomes dependent on diplomatic relations, cooperation with other governments or wider political circumstances.

From migrants' experiences to the politics of deportation

Radziwinowiczówna has studied deportation for several years. In an earlier project, she examined the experiences of people deported from the United States to Mexico. She conducted ethnographic research in a small town in southern Mexico and in the US, focusing on how deportation was experienced by migrants themselves and their communities.

In another project, which she is currently concluding, she is examining the development of a deportation regime in the United Kingdom following Brexit. Britain's withdrawal from the European Union changed immigration rules, including the regulations governing the deportation of EU citizens.

It was during this research that she became increasingly interested in the social and legal factors driving the deportation of foreign nationals.

She also collaborated with Aleksandra Gałasińska on research into the public narratives used to justify deportation. The researchers found that the British press, particularly right-wing outlets, portrayed citizens from Central and Eastern European countries as “natural born criminals”.

According to Radziwinowiczówna, this narrative was prominent during the Brexit referendum campaign and helped justify Britain's departure from the EU and the end of free movement. It subsequently paved the way for deportations to countries in Central and Eastern Europe.

REDIRECT will build on this earlier work but shift the focus away from the individual experiences of migrants and deportees towards the wider social mechanisms behind deportation.

“REDIRECT aims to lay the foundations for a sociology of deportation. It seeks to reorient research from a focus on the experiences of migrants and deportees toward an investigation into the social causes behind this extreme form of exclusion,” she told PAP.

The project will be the first ERC-funded grant focused on contemporary migration to be carried out in Poland.

Radziwinowiczówna specialises in contemporary deportation regimes, migration policies and the experiences of people subjected to forced returns. She has received SONATA and OPUS grants from Poland's National Science Centre and held a Marie Skłodowska-Curie Individual Fellowship at the University of Wolverhampton from 2018 to 2020.

Anna Mikołajczyk-Kłębek, PAP - Science in Poland

wl/ zan/

tr. RL

 

The PAP Foundation allows free reprinting of articles from the Nauka w Polsce portal provided that we are notified once a month by e-mail about the fact of using the portal and that the source of the article is indicated. On the websites and Internet portals, please provide the following address: Source: www.scienceinpoland.pl, while in journals – the annotation: Source: Nauka w Polsce - www.scienceinpoland.pl. In case of social networking websites, please provide only the title and the lead of our agency dispatch with the link directing to the article text on our web page, as it is on our Facebook profile.

More on this topic

  • Adobe Stock

    Does ‘time heals all wounds’? What grieving people really need

  • Credit: SWPS University

    Polish psychotherapist makes history with top European therapy post

Before adding a comment, please read the Terms and Conditions of the Science in Poland forum.